St. George Island is a hidden gem on Florida’s Gulf Coast, known for its stunning beaches and charming atmosphere, but beyond its natural beauty, the island is also a culinary paradise. Whether you’re in the mood for fresh seafood, classic American dishes, or a slice of pizza, St. George Island has something to satisfy every palate.
Dive into this guide to discover some of the must-visit restaurants on the island, perfect for refueling after a day of sun and sand.
Blue Parrot Ocean Front Cafe
With its breathtaking views and laid-back vibe, the Blue Parrot Ocean Front Cafe is a must-visit spot on St. George Island. This local favorite offers a diverse menu that includes fresh seafood, juicy burgers, and delicious appetizers. Dine on the outdoor deck, where pets are welcome, while enjoying a refreshing drink and watching the waves crash against the shore.
Paddy’s Raw Bar
If you’re a seafood lover, Paddy’s Raw Bar should be at the top of your list during your stay in one of our vacation rentals in St. George Island. Known for its casual atmosphere and friendly service, this bayfront eatery specializes in fresh oysters and a variety of delectable seafood options. Enjoy live music seven nights a week while catching stunning sunsets from the outdoor deck, which is also pet-friendly. Paddy’s Raw Bar truly embodies the spirit of St. George Island, making it a perfect stop for anyone exploring the island’s culinary scene.

Beach Pit
For those craving a taste of the South, the Beach Pit is a fantastic choice. This barbecue joint is known for its smoked meats, hearty sides, and laid-back environment, serving delicious breakfast options as well. Indulge in tender pulled pork, brisket, and homemade sauces. The Beach Pit also offers vegetarian options, ensuring everyone in your crew can find something delicious. After a satisfying meal, you can retreat to your St. George Island rentals for a cozy night in or head back to the beach for a sunset stroll.
Harry A’s Bar and Grill
Harry A’s Bar and Grill is another local staple that perfectly captures the island’s relaxed vibe. This family-friendly restaurant features a diverse menu with something for everyone, from fresh seafood to burgers and salads. The lively atmosphere is perfect for enjoying a night out, and you can often catch live music on the weekends. Harry A’s is particularly famous for its shrimp and grits, a Southern classic that is not to be missed.
BJ’s Pizza and Subs
When you’re in the mood for something quick and casual, BJ’s Pizza and Subs has you covered. This beloved eatery serves up delicious pizzas, subs, and salads in a relaxed setting. Whether you prefer classic pepperoni or a unique specialty pie, BJ’s offers a wide range of toppings to customize your meal. It’s the perfect place to grab a slice after a day of adventure or to order takeout to enjoy at your St. George Island vacation rentals.
Mango Mike’s
Mango Mike’s is a vibrant restaurant known for its fun atmosphere and flavorful dishes. With a menu that features everything from seafood to tropical-inspired cocktails, this spot is perfect for a lively dinner. The coconut shrimp and key lime pie are standout dishes that perfectly encapsulate the island’s flavor. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or just enjoying a night out, Mango Mike’s is a delightful place to dine with friends or family.
Book Your St. George Island Vacation Rentals With Sandcastles Vacation Rentals!
After exploring the restaurants of St. George Island, it’s time to find the perfect place to stay. At Sandcastles Vacation Rentals, we offer a wide variety of St. George Island vacation rentals that cater to any type of vacation crew. Whether you’re seeking a St. George Island beachfront vacation rental or an SGI rental with a private pool, our properties are designed to provide comfort and convenience. Enjoy easy access to the island’s attractions, restaurants, and, of course, the stunning beaches. Book your dream getaway today and make unforgettable memories on beautiful St. George Island!